Portfolios and Scenarios in Meisterplan – What’s the Difference?

PMO team using Meisterplan scenarios and portfolios.

A topic that seems to cause a certain amount of confusion among Meisterplan users is the difference between portfolios and scenarios. The purpose of this article is to explain these two areas of functionality so that you understand what each of them does and what they are best used for.

In simple terms:

  • portfolio is a filtered subset of the data

  • scenario is a copy of the data.

Scenarios in Meisterplan

When a Meisterplan system is set up the data is initially loaded into the Plan of Record (PoR). This may be regarded as the master data for the system and care should be taken that access to update this data is strictly controlled via user access. On the “Rights” tab of the “Edit User Account” dialog box (accessed from the Menu under Manage>Users>Edit User) is a checkbox to manage this:

Leaving this unchecked for the majority of users will allow you to ensure that changes to the PoR can be controlled.

To create a new scenario click on the Scenario dropdown (this displays the name of the current scenario, initially it will be “Plan of Record) near the top left hand side of the screen and select “Manage Scenarios”:

Manage scenarios in Meisterplan

This will open the Scenario Manager screen:

Scenario Manager in Meisterplan

If you click “+ Add Scenario” a new scenario will be generated as a copy of the PoR. You need to give it a name and have the option of specifying which users are able to edit it:

Add scenario in Meisterplan

We recommend creating a new scenario each planning cycle (typically monthly but could be weekly or even daily as required) and granting access to the users who need to update it. All planning work is then carried out within the scenario and changes may be applied to the PoR either individually (By right-clicking on the project and selecting “Submit Project to Plan of Record”) or as a whole by selecting the scenario from the menu and clicking “Submit Scenario as Plan of Record”. For either of these cases the user must have Plan of Record Edit Rights as noted above.

This however is not the only use of Scenarios. They may also be used for:

Evaluating Options – use a scenario to model the effects of potential changes in the portfolio. e.g. adding new projects, changing resource availability levels or  adjusting priorities. You can also use an existing scenario as your base rather than the PoR. To do this click on a scenario in the Scenario Manager and select Copy Scenario. This enables you to try multiple options before committing them to your current planning scenario or, by creating two or more scenarios, model a number of options to see which give the best result.

Making a backup – we always recommend creating a new scenario from the PoR before either committing a planning scenario as the new PoR or loading data. If anything goes wrong this means that you can restore your data to a known baseline by setting the backup as the PoR.

Working with Scenarios

When you open a scenario you have the option to compare it with any of the other scenarios that exist, including the PoR by selecting it in the Scenario Comparison area at the bottom of the Scenario Manager screen. If you use this option any changes that are made to the projects may be seen against the compared scenario:

Compare scenarios in Meisterplan

The thin grey bar above the project shows its position in the compared scenario. Whilst there is currently no Undo function, if you right click on a project you have the option to restore it to its original position by selecting “Apply Project from Compared Scenario”.

Apply project from compared scenario

If you wish to compare multiple options, or to save the changes that you’ve made without committing them to the PoR, you can use the “Copy Scenario” button on the Scenario Manager page to use any scenario as the start point.

Scenario Limitations

Within a scenario you can change the dates of projects, their allocations and milestones and also resourcing levels without affecting the PoR. However, the project metadata (e.g. the information stored in custom fields and accessed via the “Edit Project” screen) is not scenario specific and changes made here will affect the whole system.

One of the options for scenarios is to make them available for use with external reporting (e.g., using Tableau or Power BI). Currently the system only supports up to 10 scenarios using this feature so, if you are creating new scenarios regularly, it will be necessary to manage which are available for inclusion in reports.

Portfolios in Meisterplan

In Meisterplan, Portfolios are a way of grouping projects with a common aspect. This may be related to the department performing the work, the type of project, the customer the work is for or whatever you define. A common usage is to allow the managers of departments to see only their own projects and the resources allocated to them and allow each manager to focus on the projects that they are responsible for.

To create a Portfolio click on the Portfolio dropdown at the top left of the screen and select “Manage Portfolios”:

Manage portfolios in Meisterplan.

This will launch the “Portfolio Manager” screen:

Portfolio Manager in Meisterplan.

Click “Add Portfolio”:

Add portfolio in Meisterplan.

Give the Portfolio a name and assign rights to the users that need to see it. Use the Project Filter or Resource Filter tabs to define the Portfolio contents:

Edit portfolio in Meisterplan.

You can use any Lookup type fields or an OBS to select the projects that will be included. The options for Resources are more limited, the OBS is probably the most useful option:

Add filters in Meisterplan.

You can use either project or resource filters or a combination of the two.

Ready to Try Scenario and Portfolio Planning with Meisterplan?

Kundenreferenz

“Meisterplan is critical to the management of our project portfolio.”

Phil Morris, Head of PMO, First Utility

Working with Portfolios

When you select a Portfolio the projects and resources are filtered according to the settings you have selected. In this example there is a project filter set to show projects for the customer “Eagle” and a resource filter to show only resources from the Professional Services Department:

Sample portfolio in Meisterplan.

Only the projects for the selected customer are shown. All resources allocated to the projects are shown, regardless of whether they are in the selected department. Again, if you look at the allocations for a project you will see all of the allocated resources:

Resources allocated to projects in the portfolio.

However, those which do not belong to the selected department are marked with an icon to their right to indicate that they are from outside the portfolio:

Outside portfolio icon for resources

Those resources may not be amended within this portfolio. Also, only resources from within the selected department may be added to projects in this portfolio.

Similarly, if a resource is selected all of the projects to which they are allocated will be shown, with those outside the portfolio indicated by an icon to their right:

Outside portfolio icon for projects

Using Scenarios and Portfolios in a Lean PPM Process

A lean process needs to be easily understood and add minimal overhead for the users. This is an example of how Scenarios and Portfolios can be incorporated into such a process for monthly update and approval of project and resourcing plans, an example of which is shown below:

How to use scenarios and portfolios in Lean PPM.

In this example the Project Managers work within Portfolios during the month to update their plans. This could be done in the Plan of Record, although some customers prefer to use a specific planning scenario for this purpose.

Towards the end of the month the PMO creates a new Scenario from the working plans and uses this to reconcile any scheduling conflicts and optimise the overall portfolio of work.

The PMO then creates a further scenario to present the proposed revisions to the board. Using a separate scenario enables any changes agreed at the meeting to be tracked. Once approved this Scenario is set as the new Plan of Record and the process is repeated the following month.

Summary

When considering whether a scenario or portfolio is the right solution for your requirement, refer back to this post.

Use a scenario to:

  • show a specific subset of projects.

  • show a specific group of users.

  • restrict access to specific projects or resources.

Use a portfolio to:

  • only show specific projects.

  • represent a specific group of users.

  • control access rights to relevant projects and resources.

Of course, you can also use a mix of scenarios and portfolios in Meisterplan, as most of our customers do.

If you haven’t yet tried scenario and portfolio planning in Meisterplan, why wait? Start your free trial today!

By |2018-09-14T15:25:55+00:00September 14th, 2018|Categories: Project Portfolio Management|

About the Author: Kevin Johnson

Kevin Johnson is a Consultant with our partner Sandhill Consultants in the UK. He has nearly 20 years’ experience of implementing PPM systems for large and small organizations across Europe and the US, covering a wide range of sectors. He particularly enjoys the challenge of finding solutions to unusual requests.